Soldier Blog Post

Arab/Muslim Americans

November 9, 2009

I was planning on starting this entry off by talking about how life is treating me here at the last 100 meters of this marathon of learning Arabic, but in light of what has happened at Ft. Hood this last week I would like to take this opportunity to share my thoughts on its affects as someone who has learned a great deal about Arabs and Muslims over the last year and a half.

When I returned from lunch the other day reports of the shootings had just begun to broadcast. We all sat down to start our afternoon classes and one by one students would come in asking "have you heard".

Our teaching team leader, a Sudanese man with a PhD, happened to be teaching our section that hour and I asked him the same. His first comment was... and I'll never forget this... "please tell me it was not an Arab or a Muslim". Those words resonated with me because I suddenly became more aware of what it meant to HIM. He is an American citizen, just like you and me. He loves this country, just as we do.

Most of the time he knows more about this country than those of us who were born here simply because he had to WORK to earn the privilege of calling himself and American. That comment made me realize the plight of Muslim Americans. I felt a degree of sadness because they are continually being linked with extremism simply because of their faith.

As I have come to appreciate, Muslim Americans are here exactly as the rest of us. They came from foreign countries to make a better life for themselves in a land that promises freedom and rewards hard work. With the exception of the slave trade, native Americans and indentured servitude, didn't most of us come here by the same road?

I see Arabs and Muslims every day. Most are teachers, some are Soldiers, Sailors, Airmen and Marines. They are ALL fundamentally like anyone else I know. They work hard, play hard, love their families, and their neighbors. They are some of the most friendly and hospitable people you will ever meet. They want the same things as everyone else: to earn a decent living, provide for their families, enjoy life, and better themselves. They are here because they accept our culture and respect others'. All they ask is for the same respect and opportunity the rest of us enjoy.

It is sometimes too easy to act on our emotions and condemn an entire group because of the viciousness of a few individuals. But we must resist the temptation to lump the overwhelming majority of this group who live peacefully among us into a category with the same types of individuals who use a twisted version of religion to justify acts of violence. The shooter at Ft. Hood is an example of what these Americans stand against. They are no more accepting of his actions than any non-Muslims would be of a crazed Southern Baptist or Catholic opening fire at a crowded mosque. If you think that would be a good idea, I pray you will consider what gives you the right to think as such. If you think the right comes from God, then I pray you will also consider what makes you different from those you hate. This country is called a melting pot for a reason. America does not belong to any one group, sect, religion, race, creed, or otherwise. It belongs to Americans, ALL of them. It is an IDEA, unique in the history of the world. It was built by the blood and sweat of people who came here from everywhere, not just Europe. I have personal friends who are Muslims and they are already telling me stories of rude comments being made to them because of what happened at Hood. I am certain this was on my teacher's mind when made his comment, likely thinking of his children and what they might suffer because of this man's actions.

Just imagine that the shooter in Texas was someone from your own group. See what I'm getting at here? I will get off my soapbox now...

Okay, on to other news. As you can see... new postings are far and few between these days. I am holding my nose to the grindstone and there isn't really anything new to tell you. We are practicing, practicing, reviewing, and practicing... even on Saturdays now. My oral proficiency interview is on the 18th, so I have 10 days to ready myself for that. Then we start the DLPT the next week. The light is at the end of the tunnel. I don't plan on posting again until its all done, unless something significant happens between now and then. Wish me luck!

     Previous Post

T-minus 5 Weeks and Counting
October 16, 2009

Next Post     

Not My Finest Hour
December 2, 2009

  • 5 Comments
  • Add Favorite
    You must be logged in to use this feature.

Comments

  • Josh

    Nov 9, 2009 2:45 PM

    What are your thoughts to those that say this is a religious war?


    Reply

  • Wayne Wall

    Nov 9, 2009 4:11 PM

    Josh,

    In my opinion there is a big difference between "religion" and "religious extremism". What these people are doing is outside of their declared religion. And they know it. That's why they can't show themselves in 99.99% of the world. To say we are fighting Islam is a falsehood. We are fighting a very, very small group of people who have contorted that religion into a mandate from God to commit acts of unspeakable cruelty. That is NOT Islam.

    THEY may think they are God's holy warriors, but make no mistake about it, we are not fighting Muslims, we are fighting terrorists.

    That's my take on it...


    Reply

  • azubrow

    Nov 10, 2009 12:57 AM

    Maj. Wall,

    Let me say that I think you did an excellent job spelling out the problem here, and if I may, I'd just like to supplement what you've said with a couple of observations.

    Firstly, yes, what we are fighting is not a religious war; not in the least is it a religious war. I know that, you know that, the DoD knows that, and the government knows that. But, do the people know that? That's the problem, on both sides, I think.

    Take the average American who goes about his daily life without the rich multi-cultural interactions that you get to have. When he hears or sees about some act and it's been committed by some foreign sounding terrorist with some alien religion, people start to stereotype and lump together. This is exactly what these kuffar want. Every time they spread fitna through their terror acts and become true takfir (but martyrs in their own eyes), they want people to lump all Arabs and Muslims together and *make* it a holy war... it's excellent for recruiting!

    Think about it. Whenever someone in the American public refers to our righteous fight against terror wherever we find it as a 'crusade', the Muslims take notice. It's exactly what terror leaders like UBL want! It's a loaded word for them. So then what happens? The thinking probably goes a little something like this:

    Well, I'm not a jihadist or Muslim extremist, but the dar al-harb is going to treat me like one anyway.. may as well join the jihadist cause.

    Now, that may be overstating or over simplifying the case, but I imagine it occurs more than anyone would care to admit. What we have to do is educate, then isolate, then dispense justice.

    We know that it isn't a fight against Islam. But, how many in the public know that Muslim chaplains obtained a fatwa allowing those Muslim soldiers to fight against the unholy elements perverting Islam. Not many. We have to show the people that it IS NOT a war of West versus Islam, but the World against those elements that have taken a beautiful religion and twisted and perverted it into something that brings destruction and suffering for their own ends.

    That, sir, is just my two cents. (Okay, reviewing it, it's more like ten cents)


    Reply

  • Mary Constantino

    Nov 12, 2009 8:17 AM

    Well said MAJ Wall!


    Reply

  • Matt

    Nov 30, 2009 9:18 AM

    Josh - I know you're not asking me, but I'm in the same boat as MAJ Wall (kind of), having interacted with the same teachers for the past year.

    The most dangerous part of the "religious war" concept is as azubrow spelled out. When W called our fight a crusade, that surely drove more neutrals into the extremist camp. They're very good at PR, our enemy. It's hard for an observer who's not engrossed in a military job to overlook all the religious cues we have on our side as well. Gravestones are crosses, chaplains wear crosses, prayers are said at military functions, bibles are handed out at basic training, etc. That said we don't really have another choice if we cared to try to appease the extremists (not that we would). If we tried to be secular by getting rid of the religious symbols then we'd still be infidels, just secular infidels instead of judeo-christian ones.

    Enough of my rambling, I couldn't sleep and was up all night gaming.

    Matt


    Reply

Add Comment


All fields required

Your IP: 38.107.179.209